Refugee Advocates Warn Bill C-22 Could Sever Critical Communication Lifelines in Canada

Advocates for refugees and newcomers in Canada are raising concerns that Bill C-22, a federal lawful access bill under Senate review, could force encrypted messaging services like WhatsApp to withdraw from the country. While technology companies warn the legislation may compel them to break encryption or exit the market, the government maintains it does not require systemic vulnerabilities.

A federal lawful access bill currently under review by the Canadian Senate is drawing sharp warnings from refugee advocates and technology companies, who say it could lead to the withdrawal of encrypted messaging services such as WhatsApp from the Canadian market.

Bill C-22 would require technology companies to adapt their systems to provide private communications to Canadian law enforcement and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) during investigations. The legislation would also mandate that companies retain users' metadata for six months.

Editorial illustration

During a Senate committee hearing on Monday, representatives from major messaging platforms outlined the potential consequences of the bill. Rachel Curran, Meta's head of public policy for Canada, stated that the company "would need to consider" withdrawing affected services, including WhatsApp, if Bill C-22 passes. WhatsApp currently has more than three billion users worldwide, and a single group chat can accommodate more than 1,000 people exchanging messages.

Udbhav Tiwari, vice-president of strategy and global affairs at Signal, told the committee that his firm would be forced into a stark choice: either engineer a vulnerability into its platform or refuse to comply with the law, which would result in no service for Canadian users.

The federal government disputes the tech industry's interpretation. On Friday, David Taylor, a spokesperson for Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree, stated that the legislation does not permit or require companies to introduce systemic vulnerabilities or back doors.

Editorial illustration

For organizations supporting newcomers, the potential loss of these platforms represents a severe threat to daily operations and safety. Raymond Gukiina, executive director of the National Network for Immigrants and Refugees-Canada, uses WhatsApp groups to help refugees find shelter beds and share information about services in Toronto.

Alina Murad, director of federal government relations at The Refugee Centre, described WhatsApp as a crucial tool and a "lifeline" for refugee resettlement and integration. Losing access to the platform would disrupt community support networks and hinder the ability of newcomers to maintain ties with family abroad.

Lauren Lallemand, co-executive director of the Canadian Council for Refugees, noted that WhatsApp's encryption provides a necessary level of safety for people who have fled persecution, including journalists and human rights defenders. Advocates warn that without encrypted communication, these vulnerable populations face increased risks from transnational surveillance and repression.

Sources