Quebecor's $31-Billion Bid for Telus Faces Steep Regulatory Hurdles

Quebecor Inc. has proposed a $31-billion acquisition of Telus Corp., but telecommunications analysts and legal experts doubt the deal can clear Canada's stricter competition laws, spectrum transfer moratoriums, and the challenge of finding a buyer for Freedom Mobile.

Quebecor Inc. has made a $31-billion offer to buy Telus Corp., a proposed transaction that telecommunications analysts say faces significant doubts about whether it can clear all regulatory hurdles in Canada. Editorial illustration

The deal echoes the earlier merger between Rogers and Shaw, which the Competition Bureau challenged over concerns about combining their mobile arms. That transaction was ultimately approved after the companies agreed to sell Freedom Mobile to Quebecor’s Videotron subsidiary. At the time of the Rogers-Shaw deal, Videotron had 1.7 million wireless subscribers, while Freedom had 2.3 million. Following that merger, prices for mobile data plans fell by between 27 and 45 per cent from January 2023 to September 2025, with consumers paying roughly the same amount before inflation but receiving more data.

However, the regulatory landscape has shifted considerably since then. The Competition Act now contains a presumption that mergers crossing certain Herfindahl-Hershman Index (HHI) thresholds lessen or prevent competition substantially, shifting the burden of proof to the merging parties. A Quebecor-Telus merger would cross those HHI thresholds and thus be presumed to lessen or prevent competition substantially. Furthermore, the efficiencies defence was removed from the Competition Act in 2023, meaning efficiencies cannot save a merger deemed to lessen competition substantially.

To address competition concerns, the merging parties would likely need to divest Freedom Mobile, just as Rogers and Shaw did. Yet there is currently no obvious purchaser for Freedom Mobile with an established wireless business and financial strength comparable to Videotron. Editorial illustration

Beyond competition law, the deal requires approvals from Industry, Science and Economic Development Canada (ISED) for Quebecor to acquire Telus’s spectrum. ISED declared a moratorium on large-scale spectrum transfers in 2023, giving the Minister of Industry veto power over the deal through spectrum transfer approvals. Complicating matters further, Freedom’s spectrum is subject to a freeze until 2033 as a condition of Videotron acquiring it.

Michael Osborne, a legal expert at Cozen O’Connor LLP, is among those who have examined the challenges facing the transaction. With strict competition laws, spectrum transfer moratoriums, and the absence of a clear buyer for Freedom Mobile, the proposed merger faces potential failure across multiple regulatory fronts.

Sources