Canada's First Full Climate Trial Concludes Witness Testimony in Vancouver
Witness testimony has wrapped up in La Rose et al. v Canada, the country's first full climate lawsuit trial, brought by 15 youth plaintiffs who argue inadequate federal action on emissions violates their constitutional rights. Closing statements are scheduled for February as other climate cases advance across Canada.
The first full trial for a climate lawsuit in Canada has concluded its witness phase. In La Rose et al. v Canada, five weeks of hearings wrapped up on Friday in Federal Court in Vancouver, with lawyers for both sides set to return in February for one week of closing statements.

The case was brought by 15 youth applicants in 2019. The plaintiffs argue that the federal government's inadequate actions to reduce carbon emissions violate their constitutional rights. During the trial, a dozen expert witnesses and the young plaintiffs testified.
In its defence, the government argued that Canada's emissions form a very small part of global emissions. Andrew Leach, an economist at the University of Alberta, testified that stopping Canadian oil exports would not necessarily prevent those emissions from occurring elsewhere.
Legal experts note that these cases build upon each other, supported by evolving climate science and international legal opinions. Last year, the International Court of Justice released a legal opinion stating countries have a legal duty to address climate change under international law. Canada co-sponsored a non-binding resolution in the UN General Assembly supporting the ICJ's opinion, which was adopted with a vast majority.

While the landmark La Rose case awaits its conclusion, other climate-related lawsuits are progressing across Canada. On Nov. 18, a lawsuit was filed against the province of Quebec for delaying an emissions target. In Ontario, Mathur et al. v Ontario was filed in 2019 after Premier Doug Ford's government weakened provincial emissions targets; that case was put on hold after the Ford government repealed the law requiring it to set an emissions target.
A new federal suit, Maltais et al. v Canada, targets the government's Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act. The Maltais case received an early boost when a judge decided it could proceed despite the government's request for dismissal.