Liberal MPs Agree to Minor Amendments on Bill C-39 as Debate Over Fast-Tracked Projects Intensifies

The Carney government's Liberal MPs have accepted minor amendments to Bill C-39, the Building Canada Strong Act, which seeks to fast-track approvals for major projects like mines and pipelines. While opposition parties secured some transparency measures and Liberals proposed curbing pipeline approval powers, environmentalists argue the changes fail to address the bill's threat to federal safeguards.

Liberal MPs in the Carney government have agreed to make limited changes to Bill C-39, known as the Building Canada Strong Act, a sweeping legislative package designed to speed up the approval of major infrastructure projects across Canada.

Editorial illustration

Liberals describe the legislation as one of the most important economic bills in a generation. The act aims to enable federal decisions on mines, pipelines, and power lines within a one-year timeline. However, the bill contains more than 300 clauses that amend over a dozen separate pieces of federal legislation, including laws protecting species at risk, water quality, fisheries, and the Labour Code. Unions have expressed frustration over the proposed changes to the Labour Code included in the package.

Environmentalists claim that Bill C-39 guts Canada's environmental safeguards, sparking nationwide protests in cities including Thunder Bay and Whitehorse. Advocates fear the legislation will reduce accountability and allow projects to be "rubber stamped" in designated zones.

During committee proceedings, Conservative MPs secured an amendment requiring the review agency to post a copy of any early project work online. This change would allow opponents to challenge activities in Federal Court before they begin. Isabel McMurray, a lawyer with Ecojustice, stated that the current amendments are small attempts at harm reduction that do not change the balance of harms proposed by the bill.

Editorial illustration

Liberal MPs are also proposing new curbs on the Canada Energy Regulator's powers to approve pipelines without cabinet approval. When the bill was first tabled in September, it stated the regulator could approve pipelines under 300 kilometres long on its own, but a buried clause allowed approval for any length without cabinet sign-off. The new Liberal proposal specifically addresses this issue.

Meanwhile, Conservatives, the Bloc Québécois, New Democrats, and the Green Party are pushing for changes to place guardrails around the cabinet's power to designate regions of national interest, such as the Ring of Fire. NDP MP Leah Gazan proposed changes to protect Indigenous constitutional rights and strengthen free prior and informed consent; Liberals supported one of her amendments but rejected most others.

Committee proceedings were temporarily suspended after NDP MP Heather McPherson raised a privilege issue when CBC News obtained the full list of 228 pages of amendments before they were introduced to the committee.

A new report indicates that federal permitting is rarely a bottleneck for clean energy projects, citing delayed engagement with Indigenous nations and lack of community involvement as primary factors slowing development.

Sources