Patient Dies Outside Port Hardy Hospital Minutes After Emergency Department Closes

A woman died outside Port Hardy Hospital on northern Vancouver Island shortly after its emergency department closed for the day, intensifying concerns about reduced rural healthcare access in British Columbia caused by ongoing staffing shortages.

A woman died outside Port Hardy Hospital on northern Vancouver Island just minutes after the facility’s emergency department closed for the day, renewing public concern over rural emergency care access in British Columbia.

Editorial illustration

According to B.C. Emergency Health Services (BCEHS), a paramedic became aware of a patient needing treatment in the hospital parking lot at 5:11 p.m. on Thursday, Nov. 19—only 11 minutes after the emergency department’s scheduled 5 p.m. closing time. Two additional ambulances responded to the scene, and paramedics provided emergency treatment before transferring the patient to hospital staff in critical condition. The patient subsequently died.

Island Health confirmed that health-care providers and BCEHS paramedics responded to the incident and stated that the circumstances of the case are under review.

North Island MLA Anna Kindy identified the deceased as a woman and expressed her condolences. She noted that while emergency staff were available in this particular instance, they often are not in rural communities.

The Port Hardy Hospital emergency department has operated with reduced hours since early 2023 due to staffing shortages. Health officials concentrated overnight emergency services at Port McNeill, leaving Port Hardy’s ER open only from 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. When the Port Hardy ER is closed, patients requiring emergency care must be transported to Port McNeill, a 45-kilometre drive away. Port Hardy Mayor Pat Corbett-Labatt described the reduced-hours arrangement as one that was supposed to be temporary. She added that staffing shortages have led to repeated ER closures across north Island hospitals, including those in Port Hardy, Port McNeill, and Alert Bay.

Paul Adams, executive director of the B.C. Rural Health Network, noted that similar service disruptions affect hospitals across northern and Interior B.C. due to recruitment and retention challenges.

Editorial illustration

Port Hardy Hospital opened in 1980 and handles more than 6,000 emergency department visits annually. Earlier this year, the province announced a $45-million expansion and upgrade of the hospital, which is expected to be completed in phases by 2029. However, despite the investment, the province has not established when the hospital's emergency department might return to 24-hour operations.

Sources