Liberal Government Refuses to Separate Advance Requests from Mental Illness Provisions in MAID Bill C-41

Justice Minister Sean Fraser announced the Liberal government will not split advance directives from mental illness provisions in Bill C-41, which updates medically assisted dying legislation. Conservative MPs criticized bundling the amendments without separate votes.

Justice Minister Sean Fraser has announced that the Liberal government will not pull advance directives out of Bill C-41 for a separate vote. The bill, which updates Canada's medically assisted dying (MAID) legislation, was introduced in the House of Commons on October 27. Editorial illustration

Bill C-41 contains two principal amendments. One bans individuals from receiving MAID if their sole underlying condition is a mental illness, while the other allows people with diminishing mental capacity to request MAID in advance.

Conservative MP Andrew Lawton questioned why the bill was not split into separate votes, noting there is no legislative timeline requirement for advance requests. In response, Fraser argued that delaying advance requests would cause unnecessary suffering for those losing mental capacity. He stated his motivation for moving forward expeditiously was based on conversations with suffering individuals rather than medical advice.

Fraser emphasized that proper safeguards are in place for advance requests. These include sign-off by an expert doctor and independent assessments by two separate medical assessors regarding intolerable suffering and incurability.

The debate over MAID eligibility follows years of legal and legislative changes. In 2019, the Superior Court of Quebec struck down the original 2016 MAID law because it limited eligibility to those whose deaths were "reasonably foreseeable." Parliament subsequently passed Bill C-7 in March 2021, which removed that requirement and temporarily delayed the expansion of MAID to cases involving only mental illness.

The mental health provision for MAID has been delayed multiple times, most recently to March 2027. If Bill C-41 is not passed or the dates are pushed back again, MAID will automatically expand to cover mental illness in March 2027.

Sources