Meta Warns It May Pull Encryption Services From Canada Over Bill C-22

Meta representatives told the Canadian Senate that the company would consider withdrawing encryption services from Canada if Bill C-22 passes without further amendments. Signal and Apple have also raised concerns about the legislation's impact on user privacy and security.

Meta representatives testified before the Canadian Senate on Monday evening, warning that the company would have to "consider" pulling encryption services from Canada if the lawful access bill, known as Bill C-22, passes without further changes.

Editorial illustration

Robyn Greene, Meta's director of privacy and public policy, told senators that enforcing the law as proposed is not technically feasible while still offering secure, end-to-end encrypted services. Rachel Curran, Meta's head of public policy for Canada, stated that government amendments do not go far enough to protect encrypted data. She specifically noted that the amendments protect only the core and not outside layers integral to the encryption process.

Bill C-22 grants the minister authority to issue confidential ministerial orders requiring electronic service providers to build surveillance and monitoring capabilities into their systems. Earlier this month, Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree proposed amendments that reduced the metadata retention period for tech companies from up to a year to six months.

Other major technology companies have expressed similar opposition. Signal vice-president Udbhav Tiwari told the Senate committee that Signal would withdraw from Canada rather than compromise user security if forced to choose between betraying users and leaving. Apple issued a statement saying the amendments to Bill C-22 are not enough and could undermine its ability to offer expected privacy and security features, including encryption.

Editorial illustration

Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne urged the Senate in June to further amend the legislation. He noted that the definition of subscriber information remains overly broad relative to the lowered legal threshold for access. Critics argue that the bill could lead to compromised security of end-to-end encrypted communications for Canadians and increased vulnerability of encrypted data to malicious actors.

Sources