Canada to Indefinitely Suspend MAID Expansion for Mental Illness
Justice Minister Sean Fraser announced legislation to indefinitely exclude individuals whose sole medical condition is mental illness from medically assisted dying, while introducing advance consent provisions for patients with incurable illnesses.
Canadian Justice Minister Sean Fraser announced on Wednesday that the federal government will introduce legislation to indefinitely suspend plans to expand medically assisted dying (MAID) to individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. 
The current exclusion of MAID for mental illness as a sole criterion was set to expire in March 2027. The new legislation will maintain this exclusion on an indeterminate basis. The expansion had previously been scheduled for 2023 and then delayed to 2024.
Fraser stated there is no perfect consensus on the issue but believes suspension is the correct approach at this time. He cited two main reasons for the exclusion: concerns about inadequate access to mental health services and the lack of medical consensus on when a mental illness is incurable.
The decision follows a report released in June by a special parliamentary committee, which recommended that Canada indefinitely exclude persons whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness from assisted dying. Some committee members dissented from the recommendation, calling the process fundamentally flawed and biased.
Supporters of expansion argue that excluding mental illness violates constitutional rights, while opponents cite the lack of medical consensus on incurability and inadequate mental health infrastructure. Critics argue the delay violates constitutional rights and access to healthcare for those with mental illness.
In addition to maintaining the exclusion, the proposed legislation will allow patients with progressing incurable illnesses to provide advance consent for assisted dying before they lose the capacity to do so. Final decisions on advanced requests may be left up to individual provinces.
Conservative MP Tamara Jansen introduced private member's bill C-218 addressing the issue. Fraser criticized the bill for using the term "mental disorders," which could potentially include neurodegenerative diseases, and for failing to address advance consent. Jansen accused Fraser of playing political games by announcing his own legislation hours before a vote on her bill, claiming he had ample time to prepare.

Medically assisted dying became legal in Canada in 2016 for terminal illnesses under Bill C-7 and was expanded in 2021 to include incurable conditions where death is not imminent.